Lil B's stream-of-consciousness lyrical approach remains uniquely suited to this sort of cosmic contemplation. You're unlikely to find a more guileless or gentle hip-hop record this year. "I Hate Myself" is a woozy, pitched-down loop of Goo Goo Doll's "Iris" in which the drums hit like down pillows. The production, by frequent collaborators Clams Casino, 9th Wonder, and others, reinforces the mood of naive reverie: "Gon Be Okay" samples an orchestral flourish from the soundtrack to Hayao Miyazaki's Spirited Away, while "Unchain Me" is built on a loop of "Cry Little Sister" from The Lost Boys soundtrack. He has many other faces- occasional boom-bap traditionalist, tweaker of boom-bap traditionalism, uncomfortably personal YouTube diarist- but this side is easily B's most relatable and endearing.
The album finds him securely in his dazed, child-like observer mode, where he peers at the world as if for the first time and wonders aloud. That's not to say that I'm Gay contains all of Lil B's personae. If you're intrigued by Lil B but shrink from the commitment of keeping pace with a human data stream, it might be the only record you'll ever need. His followers may debate whether Rain in England or 6 Kiss or Illusions of Grandeur or Bitch Mob: Respect Da Bitch is better (Lil B has a flair for titles), but for the uninitiated, I'm Gay does a great job of articulating his ethos and appeal in the space of one album. I'm Gay appeared on iTunes last week, and by convenience or design, it's his most coherent, cohesive, and accessible single release to date. Whatever his motivations (it probably had something to do with his philosophy of universal acceptance and self-love, but his manifestos don't survive close analysis), he guaranteed that the album's audience would be exponentially larger than anything he'd done before. With this single statement, Lil B calmly detonated a flower-power land mine in the center of what is arguably rap's most tortured, combustible political arena. And then he announced at Coachella he was going to name his next album I'm Gay.
The result was a hip-hop comedy of manners: as XXL included him on their Freshmen 2011 list alongside industry non-entities like Mac Miller and Lil Twist and Lupe Fiasco publicly congratulated himself for "getting it," B basically continued whistling his tune, collaborating with Lil Wayne and Jean Grae and Tony Yayo and rapping over How to Dress Well instrumentals. It's a self-contained musical universe, located at the vanishing point on the "all-or-nothing" spectrum, and its cult of faithful has been steadily building to the point where the mainstream rap industry has been forced to contend with him.